
Predatory journals
Critical notes (06)
John H. McCool wrote this story in one of the last issues of The Scientist (June 2017, p.23), in an article titled "Why I published in a Predatory Journal."
As part of his campaign to unmask the so-called "predatory journals" ("academic", open access, low-quality journals that invite authors to publish and charge them a large amount of money), he answered a call-for-papers from the Urology & Nephrology Open Access Journal, belonging to the infamous MedCrave Group.
He wrote a completely made-up article, based on the TV series "Seinfeld". According to the author himself, he included a terrible amount of ridicule stuff in the text, which could have been detected even by a layman in the matter, with a simple Google search.
After going through a supposed peer review, the journal's editors announced that his article had been accepted. And they wanted to charge him $ 800 for publishing it.
A popular list of confirmed and suspected "predatory journals" is Jeffrey Beall's, with more than a thousand titles.
And yes: they also exist among Librarianship and Information Sciences.
Note belonging to the series Critical notes.
About the post
Text: Edgardo Civallero.
Picture: The Scientist (link).
Etiquetas: apuntes críticos, bibliotecología crítica, bibliotecología progresista, bibliotecología social